Tag Archives | Francis Merson

Revisiting The Maestro Myth – PART II

ConductorIf I wanted to synthesize an argument and critique about the training opportunities and programs for young orchestral conductors in Australia, it could not be better encapsulated than in this gorgeous quote from conductor, Hannu Lintu, in Toby Deller’s interview with the Finnish maestro published in the January 2014 edition of Classical Music.  Hannu remarks, “In Finland, our system is ideal for young conductors. When you start to study conducting you can get jobs with the biggest orchestras in Finland because they want to be part of our schooling and part of the Finnish conducting tradition.” (Classical Music, January 2014, 36).

If Hannu had trained in Australia, the remark might have easily read, “In Australia, no system exists for training conductors. When you start to study conducting you can’t get a job either for love nor money with the biggest orchestras in Australia because they don’t want to be part of our schooling and part of the Australian conducting tradition – besides the fact, there isn’t one.”  OK, other than this misappropriation – intended with the tongue fully pressed into the cheek – the truth is, that there is a training opportunity, of sorts, in Australia through the Symphony Services Australia ‘Conductor Development Program’.  The problem with this program is that it is simply inadequate.  Sorry, scream and hurl invective all you like, it is an unfortunate and unpalatable truth.  We all know it, we just don’t dare say so, as we all know what happens thereafter behind closed doors in the very ‘cliquey’ Arts world in Australia.

James Rhodes in an article in The Guardian in September 2013 forcefully proclaimed, “The problem with classical music is that the whole industry is so deeply ashamed of itself, so unremittingly apologetic for being involved with an art form seen as irrelevant, privileged and poncey, that it has gone to unfortunate extremes to over-compensate.”  Australia’s efforts to train conductors up to this point similarly smacks of this ashamedness and apologeticism.  ‘We do it, but only because we need to seem to be’ is an uncomfortable actuality and undoubtedly prickles those who would rather evade the issue altogether.   But, let’s be fair: the SSI program has had, or at least overtly proclaims to have had, notable successes.  However, I would argue that most of these ‘notable’ successes came from the successors having lived, studied and worked overseas for lengthy periods – and not from the disjointed, part-time, and curriculum deficient training that substitutes for training budding maestri in Australia.

So what is the answer? Continue Reading →

Revisiting The Australian Maestro Myth – Part I

ConductorIn the July 2012 edition of Limelight magazine, Francis Merson wrote an incisive article entitled ‘The Australian Maestro Myth’.  What made this piece worthy beyond its inherently good style, was that it poked at the surface of the murky depths of the state of orchestral conducting in Australia from the perspective of home-grown, aspiring Australian conductors.  It doesn’t take a degree in fortune-telling to predict that the current state of play, and predictions for the future, were bleak. Continue Reading →